Swale

The Swale Worksheet is where you enter a grassed swale (with or without swale blocks) for the current catchment and see how much of the average annual runoff, nitrogen and phosphorus it removes. Open it from Treatment Options with the Swale button. You enter the swale’s shape, slope, roughness and infiltration rate, the size of the road or parking area that drains to it, and any swale blocks; BMPFast works out how much runoff the swale infiltrates and stores, turns it into a treatment depth, and reads the annual capture from the retention efficiency tables.

Description

Swales have been used for stormwater conveyance and infiltration for over 50 years. In the last 25–35 years, annual removal credit has been granted based on research and field measurements conducted in the State of Florida.

Annual removal can be quantified:

  • As a retention BMP
  • For reducing annual stormwater pollutant mass load

As a retention system, the Seasonal High Water Table (SHWT) must be at least 2 feet below the bottom of the swale to earn annual removal credit using the BMPFast removal equations. BMPFast does not ask for or check the water table; confirm it in your design.

Source reference

FDEP and the water management districts (2010). Stormwater Quality Applicant’s Handbook: Design Requirements for Stormwater Treatment Systems in Florida, March 2010 draft (not adopted), Section 9.4 Design Criteria for Swales, paragraph (b) (the draft, not adopted: PDF, 16 MB): “The seasonal high ground water table shall be at least two feet below the bottom of the swale” unless an alternative is shown; this rule is not in Volume I or Appendix O, and BMPFast does not check it.

Concentration reduction is accounted for by the residence time in the swale (Wanielista, M.P. and Yousef, Y.A. (1993). Stormwater Management. John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 244–251).

In general, concentration reduction occurs when the longitudinal slope is less than 1% (1 foot drop in 100 feet). BMPFast does not add a separate concentration reduction: the N and P removal equal the hydraulic capture.

Statutory and Design Definition

Additional design details defining a swale are found in:

  • Chapter 403.803, Florida Statutes
  • Applicant’s Handbook, Vol 1, Appendix O (June 28, 2024)

A Swale is defined as a manmade trench which:

  • Has a top width to depth ratio equal to or greater than 6:1
    OR side slopes equal to or flatter than 3 horizontal to 1 vertical
  • Contains contiguous areas of standing or flowing water only following a rainfall event
  • Is planted with or has stabilized vegetation suitable for soil stabilization, stormwater treatment, and nutrient uptake
  • Is designed considering soil erosion, soil percolation, slope, slope length, and drainage area to prevent erosion and reduce pollutant concentration of discharge

Swale Categories

Swales designed for stormwater treatment can be classified into three categories:

  1. Swales with swale blocks or raised driveway culverts
  2. Swales without swale blocks or raised driveway culverts
  3. Swales incorporated into landscaping (elongated rain garden)

Typically, swales are online retention systems, and their treatment effectiveness is directly related to the amount of annual stormwater volume infiltrated.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Swale: gives the statutory definition (Section 403.803(14), F.S.), says swales “are online retention systems” whose effectiveness depends on the annual volume infiltrated, and names two categories, with and without swale blocks or raised driveway culverts; the third category above (a swale in landscaping) is covered in Appendix O by Raingarden/Bioretention Cell and Bio Swale, also calculated as dry retention.

Section 2.0 Definitions and Terms, “Swale”: repeats the same four-part definition.

Annual removal follows the retention curves, and it is assumed the swale empties the design volume within 72 hours. (The Swale worksheet has no recovery-time input.)

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: “Recovery of the required treatment volume (Pollution Abatement Volume, or PAV) must be achieved within 72 hours or less”; BMPFast assumes this and does not check it.

Inputs

The note at the top of the worksheet reads: “Area contributing runoff to the swale is (average impervious width + average pervious width) x average impervious length as required inputs.” The two diagrams on the worksheet show the swale cross section (W, B, Z, H) and the profile with a swale block (H, Lb, S, L, and the ponded length Lw = H/S).

InputUnitsWhat it means / how it is used
Swale top width calculated for flood conditions (ft) [W]:ftTop width of the swale at the flood-control water level. The swale’s own area (W × L) is added to the impervious area as rainfall-excess area. If the pervious width below is less than W, BMPFast uses W for it; Calculate warns you and the report says so.
Swale bottom width (0 for triangular section) (ft) [B]:ftBottom width of the swale; 0 for a V-shaped (triangular) swale. Used in Manning’s equation and in the width of the water at a swale block.
Swale length (ft) [L]:ftLength of the swale. Infiltration is over this length.
Average catchment length (ft):ftLength of the road or paved area that drains to the swale (reported as “Average Impervious Length”). Usually the same as the swale length.
Average impervious width (including shoulder) (ft):ftWidth of the paved area that drains to the swale, including the shoulder.
Average width of pervious area including swale width (ft):ftWidth of the grassed area draining to the swale, including the swale itself. Used for the Swale Catchment Area Used.
Swale slope (ft drop/ft length) [S]:ft/ftLongitudinal slope of the swale. Used in Manning’s equation and for the length of water ponded behind a swale block (H / S). It must be a number greater than 0: a slope of 0 or less, a blank box, or text that is not a number (for example “0.005ft”) is refused with a message (Calculate, Plot, Sizing and Back), since both equations divide by it.
Manning’s N:–Manning’s roughness coefficient for flow in the swale. Used to find the depth of flow, and so the wetted perimeter that infiltrates.
Soil infiltration rate (in/hr):in/hrLimiting infiltration rate of the swale soil, usually from field tests and including a factor of safety.
Side slope of swale (horizontal ft/vertical ft) [Z]:ft/ftSide slope, horizontal to vertical (for example 3 for 3:1).
Average height of the swale blocks (ft) [H]:ftHeight of the swale blocks (or raised driveway culverts). 0 if there are none.
Length of the berm upstream of the crest (ft):ftLength Lb of the block’s berm upstream of its crest; it is subtracted from the ponded length behind each block.
Number of Swale blocks:–Number of swale blocks along the swale (Nb). 0 if there are none. If you enter 0 blocks but a block height H above 0, BMPFast counts one block.

The catchment’s non-DCIA curve number, DCIA percent and rainfall zone (used in the efficiency lookup) and its EMCs come from the Catchment Characteristics screen. The area draining to the swale should match the catchment’s post-development area; BMPFast does not check this, so compare the report’s Swale Catchment Area Used with the catchment area.

Example input

  • Catchment area = 1.2 acres: average catchment length 871.2 ft × (impervious width 20 ft + pervious width 40 ft) / 43,560 = 1.20 acres

Equations

Methodology. BMPFast treats this BMP as retention. Retention BMPs compares how every retention BMP calculates its Treatment Depth, and Retention Methodology explains the retention curves it is read on.

Rainfall Excess Area (ac) = (W x L + Impervious L x Impervious W) / 43560
Flow in Swale (cfs) = Rainfall Excess Area x Rainfall Intensity (rainfall zone)
Depth of Flow d: solved from Manning, Q = 1.486/n x A x R^(2/3) x S^(1/2)
A = B d + Z d^2, P = B + 2 d sqrt(Z^2 + 1), R = A / P
Infiltrated Depth (in) = [L x Infiltration Rate x P / (12 x 3600)] x 6000 x 12 / (Rainfall Excess Area x 43560)
Swale Block Storage (cf) = (w x H / 6) x (sl - Lb) x Nb, w = B + 2 Z H, sl = min(H / S, L / Nb)
Block Depth (in) = 12 x Swale Block Storage / (Rainfall Excess Area x 43560)
Treatment Depth (in) = min(4, Infiltrated Depth + Block Depth)
  • 6000 is the average storm duration in seconds used by BMPFast.
  • The rainfall intensity (in/hr) is the average annual rainfall intensity of the project’s rainfall zone: Florida Zone 1 = 0.1626, Zone 2 = 0.1848, Zone 3 = 0.1714, Zone 4 = 0.1729, Zone 5 = 0.1838. Times the Rainfall Excess Area in acres it gives the average flow in the swale in cfs (1 ac-in/hr = 1.008 cfs).
  • Swale Catchment Area Used (ac) = Average catchment length × (impervious width + pervious width) / 43560 (reported for checking).
  • Hydraulic capture efficiency is read from the retention efficiency lookup tables for the Treatment Depth, the watershed’s non-DCIA curve number, DCIA percent and rainfall zone. N and P removal are equal to the hydraulic capture efficiency.
  • If the Rainfall Excess Area is 0 (no swale or impervious area entered), the treatment depth and all removals are 0.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Swale: “The nutrient reduction capability of these systems can be calculated in the same way as Dry Retention System”; BMPFast turns the infiltrated volume and block storage into a Treatment Depth and reads the dry retention tables.

Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: the tables give mean annual mass removal by zone, non-DCIA curve number, DCIA and retention depth up to 4.00 in, with linear interpolation; BMPFast uses these tables and limits the Treatment Depth to 4 in. How the swale’s infiltration becomes a depth (Manning flow, infiltration over the wetted perimeter) is not in the Handbook; it is from FL-ER-38-88 (below).

Source of the method. The swale calculation follows Wanielista, M.P., Yousef, Y.A. and Avellaneda, E. (1988), Alternatives for the Treatment of Groundwater Contaminants: Infiltration Capacity of Roadside Swales, Report FL-ER-38-88, Florida Department of Transportation and University of Central Florida (read the report, PDF, 3.9 MB). That report solves the depth of flow in the swale from Manning’s equation and finds the length of swale needed to infiltrate an average runoff rate at the soil’s infiltration rate (in/hr) (Chapter V and Appendix A). It checked the method at two swales near Orlando: at Interstate 4 East the calculated length was 226 ft and the measured length 225 ft. The flow used is the average flow over a storm, not the peak flow. Dr. Wanielista describes it as the rational method’s peak divided by two, the average of a triangular hydrograph, with the rainfall intensity in in/hr (correspondence with the South Florida Water Management District, August 2023). BMPFast takes that average from the average annual rainfall intensity of the project’s zone, so no factor of one-half is applied to it.

Source reference

Wanielista, M.P., Yousef, Y.A. and Avellaneda, E. (1988). Alternatives for the Treatment of Groundwater Contaminants: Infiltration Capacity of Roadside Swales. Report FL-ER-38-88, FDOT and University of Central Florida, Chapter V and Appendix A (link): the depth of flow from Manning’s equation and the swale length needed to infiltrate an average runoff rate, checked at two swales near Orlando; BMPFast’s infiltrated depth follows this method.

FDEP and the water management districts (2010). Stormwater Quality Applicant’s Handbook: Design Requirements for Stormwater Treatment Systems in Florida, March 2010 draft (not adopted), Section 9.3.2, Equations 9.3.1 and 9.3.2 (the draft, not adopted: PDF, 16 MB): gives the average flow as Q = 0.5 CIA, the rational peak divided by two, with I the treatment volume over the time of concentration, and a swale length equation; BMPFast instead uses the zone’s average annual rainfall intensity.

BMPFast method (Swale.cs and IntensityLookupTable): the zone intensities (0.1626 to 0.1848 in/hr), the 6000-second average storm duration and the swale block storage (w × H / 6) × (sl − Lb) × Nb are in the program without a cited source.

Results (the report)

  • Swale Input Variables: the thirteen inputs, then Swale Catchment Area Used (acres), Rainfall Excess Area (acres) and Treatment Depth (in).
  • Watershed Characteristics: Watershed Area, Contributing Area to BMP, Non-DCIA Curve Number, DCIA Percent, Rainfall Zone and Rainfall, from the catchment.
  • Surface Water Discharge: Provided Nitrogen and Phosphorus Treatment Efficiency (%), shown at most 99%.
  • Media Mix Information (when a media mix is selected) and Groundwater Discharge (Stand-Alone) (when groundwater analysis is on or a media mix is selected): the Average Annual Recharge (MG/yr infiltrated), and the TN and TP mass loads (kg/yr) and concentrations (mg/L) reaching the groundwater.
  • Load Diagram for Swale (stand-alone, this catchment only): load in, treatment (%), surface discharge out and mass reduction for N, P and runoff volume.

Buttons

ButtonWhat it does
Calculate / Equations / ReportAfter you change an input the button reads Calculate: a click reads the boxes, calculates and shows the report. Once the report is current it reads Equations and shows the Equations page (the equations and notes above, and the current value of every input, the watershed values, Treatment Depth, Hydraulic Capture, Treatment Rate, and N and P removal); it then reads Report to switch back.
MediaOpens the Media Mix form, for example when the infiltration soils are replaced with media. It changes the groundwater results.
SizingOpens the Sizing window (below).
CostOpens the Cost Analysis for this swale.
PrintOpens the report in the Report Viewer.
PlotOpens the “Swale (retention) System Efficiency” chart (see Discovery below).
HelpOpens this page.
BackReads the boxes, calculates, saves to the project and closes the worksheet.

The bar along the bottom of the window shows the project’s Maximum % Removal for TN and TP: the removal your analysis type requires.

Sizing

How the Sizing window works, for every BMP, is on Sizing.

The Sizing window for a swale, with Swale Length plotted against the removal targets.

The Sizing window finds swale dimensions that meet your N and P removal targets. Every input above is a sizing variable, with these arrow steps and limits: W (step 1, min 1), B (step 1, min 0, a triangular section), L (step 10, min 10), average impervious length (step 10, min 1), impervious width (step 5, min 1), pervious width (step 5, min 1), S (step 0.001, 0.001 to 0.2), Manning’s N (step 0.005, 0.01 to 0.2), infiltration rate (step 0.5, min 0), Z (step 0.5, min 0), H (step 0.1, min 0), Lb (step 1, min 0) and number of blocks (step 1, min 0). Swale Length is plotted first. The window plots N and P removal against the chosen variable with the target lines (starting at the project’s Maximum % Removal), the current design and the point where both targets are met; Use sets the variable to that point. The line under the values shows the resulting treatment depth (the tables stop at 4 inches). Apply keeps the new values; Cancel puts back the ones you had.

Discovery and Optimization (Plot Feature)

Alternative designs can be evaluated using the Plot feature of BMPFast.

The plot shows the annual capture of runoff, expressed as a percent of the total annual runoff (“Runoff Capture Efficiency (% of yearly)”), as a function of the treatment (retention) depth from 0 to 4 inches, for this catchment’s curve number, DCIA and rainfall zone. A marker shows the current design.

For a specific location and design, the example plot is shown below.

By adjusting:

  • Geometric dimensions
  • Swale size
  • Replacing infiltration soils with media
  • Other design parameters

The resulting change in annual capture can be determined. The Sizing window does this directly for any one input.

Sample problems

Worked problems solved in BMPFast, each with every input, the steps with screen captures, the program’s results, a hand check and the project file to download. Captures are for demonstration only. All of them: BMPFast sample problems.