Strand Based Routing for No Treatment to Detention

A strand is No Treatment to Detention when catchments with no treatment are routed, one into the next, into a catchment with a Wet Detention pond. BMPFast calculates the untreated catchments and the pond together as one strand (see Routing). This page shows the calculation BMPFast uses, the other methods, and how far apart they are on a worked example.

The method BMPFast uses

The untreated catchments pass all their runoff and load to the pond. The pond is calculated with all the runoff reaching it, and its removal applies to all the load reaching it.

Runoff reaching the pond (ac-ft/yr) = runoff of the pond's catchment + runoff of every untreated catchment above it
Residence Time (days) = Permanent Pool (ac-ft) / Runoff reaching the pond × 365 (at most 200)
N removal (%) = 43.75 × rt / (4.38 + rt); P removal (%) = 40.13 + 6.372 ln(rt) + 0.213 [ln(rt)]²
No littoral zone: × 0.90; wetland credit added on the remaining load
Load at the outlet of the strand = all the load reaching the pond × (1 − removal / 100)

These are the Wet Detention equations (Wet Detention Methodology). A pond in a chain of ponds, and a pond where several catchments meet, are calculated the same way. The routing report’s note for the strand shows the residence time with the project’s numbers.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Wet Detention: residence time is the permanent pool volume divided by the “annual runoff inputs”, times 365; BMPFast counts as inputs all the runoff reaching the pond, including the untreated catchments above it, and applies the TP and TN percent removal equations to all the load reaching it.

Worked example

Catchment 2 (99 ac, no treatment) routed to catchment 1 (1 ac) with a wet pond of 0.1 ac-ft and a littoral zone. Catchment 2 sends 99.02 ac-ft/yr and catchment 1 adds 1.00 ac-ft/yr, so 100.02 ac-ft/yr flow through the pond. The catchments produce 100.01 kg/yr of nitrogen and 100.01 kg/yr of phosphorus.

Residence Time = 0.1 × 365 / 100.02 = 0.365 days
N removal = 43.75 × 0.365 / (4.38 + 0.365) = 3.36 %
P removal = 40.13 + 6.372 ln(0.365) + 0.213 [ln(0.365)]² = 33.92 %
N at the outlet = 100.01 × (1 − 3.36 / 100) = 96.65 kg/yr

A pool this small for 100 acres replaces its water about every 9 hours, so it removes little.

Other methods

A. The pond’s own catchment’s runoff, applied to all the load

The residence time comes from the pond’s own catchment only, but the removal is applied to all the load reaching it. It credits the pond with a residence time it does not have when the upstream water flows through it.

Residence Time (days) = Permanent Pool / runoff of the pond's own catchment × 365

B. The upstream runoff bypasses the pond

The pond treats only its own catchment, at its own residence time, and the upstream runoff goes on untreated. This is what BMPFast does when the pond’s catchment is set to bypass upstream runoff on the Routing screen: then the strand is not calculated as one system.

Load at the outlet = upstream load + own load × (1 − removal at its own residence time / 100)

The differences

MethodResidence time (days)N removal of the strand (%)P removal of the strand (%)N at the outlet (kg/yr)P at the outlet (kg/yr)
Used: all the runoff reaching the pond0.363.433.996.6566.09
A. Own catchment’s runoff, on all the load36.4939.165.860.9534.20
B. Upstream runoff bypasses the pond36.49 (own load only)0.40.799.6299.36

Method A gives far more removal than the pond can provide: it treats 100 acres of runoff as if it stayed 36 days in a pool sized for one acre. Method B treats only the pond’s own acre. The method BMPFast uses is the only one in which the pond sees the water that actually flows through it.

The methods over a range of pond sizes

Here the pond’s permanent pool goes from 0.05 to 20 ac-ft. The method used, B (catchment 1 set to bypass upstream runoff) and node by node (ComplexRouting.Calculate) were calculated by the program; node by node gives the same numbers as the method used. A is put together from the pond’s own removal in the program (WetDetention.RemovalAtResidenceTime at its own catchment’s residence time) applied to all the load.

Pool (ac-ft)Residence time: all runoff / own runoff (days)BMPFast N / P (%)A. Own runoff N / P (%)B. Bypass N / P (%)
0.050.18 / 181.7 / 29.935.3 / 60.40.4 / 0.6
0.10.36 / 363.4 / 33.939.1 / 65.80.4 / 0.7
0.250.91 / 917.5 / 39.541.7 / 73.20.4 / 0.7
0.51.82 / 18212.9 / 44.042.7 / 79.10.4 / 0.8
13.65 / 36519.9 / 48.742.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
27.30 / 73027.3 / 53.642.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
414.60 / 146033.7 / 58.742.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
829.19 / 291938.0 / 64.142.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
1243.79 / 437939.8 / 67.342.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
1658.39 / 583940.7 / 69.642.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
2072.99 / 729941.3 / 71.442.8 / 79.90.4 / 0.8
No Treatment to Detention strand: nitrogen removal by each method against the permanent pool
No Treatment to Detention strand: nitrogen removal by each method against the permanent pool
No Treatment to Detention strand: phosphorus removal by each method against the permanent pool
No Treatment to Detention strand: phosphorus removal by each method against the permanent pool

What the comparison shows

  • Method A reaches the 200-day limit with a pool of about 0.55 ac-ft, because it divides by the runoff of one acre; it then credits the strand with 42.8 % N and 79.9 % P whatever the pool.
  • The method used rises slowly: even 20 ac-ft gives a residence time of 73 days for 100 acres of runoff, 41.3 % N and 71.4 % P.
  • Bypass (B) treats only the pond’s own acre, so the strand’s removal stays under 1 %.

Source reference

BMPFast’s method (Ron, October 15, 2026): the pond equations are from Harper, H.H. and Baker, D.M. (2007), Evaluation of Current Stormwater Design Criteria within the State of Florida, final report, FDEP Contract S0108, Environmental Research & Design; calculating the pond with all the runoff reaching it is BMPFast’s method, the same as for a pond at a junction (plans 6.81 and 6.84).

Sample problems

Worked problems solved in BMPFast, each with every input, the steps with screen captures, the program’s results, a hand check and the project file to download. Captures are for demonstration only. All of them: BMPFast sample problems.