A strand is No Treatment to Retention when catchments with no treatment are routed, one into the next, into a catchment with a retention-type BMP (Retention, Exfiltration, Swale, Tree Well or a buffer set to Retention). BMPFast calculates them together as one strand (see Routing). This page shows the calculation BMPFast uses, the other methods, and how far apart they are on a worked example.
The method BMPFast uses
The untreated catchments pass all their runoff and load to the retention BMP. Its Treatment Volume is spread over all the area that drains to it, with the area-weighted Non-DCIA Curve Number and DCIA percent of those catchments, and the capture at that depth applies to all the load reaching it.
Treatment Depth (in) = 12 × Treatment Volume (ac-ft) / all the area draining to it (ac)
Non-DCIA CN, DCIA % = area-weighted averages of the catchments draining to it
Capture (%) = retention curves (Treatment Depth, CN, DCIA %, zone); N removal = P removal = Capture
Load at the outlet of the strand = all the load reaching the BMP × (1 − Capture / 100)
The Treatment Volume is the BMP’s storage (Retention BMPs): a basin’s Provided Retention Volume, an exfiltration trench’s voids, and so on. A retention BMP where several catchments meet is calculated the same way. The routing report’s note for the strand shows the depth with the project’s numbers.
Applicant’s Handbook reference
Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: the design volume is “expressed as inches over the catchment area” and adjusted for the non-DCIA CN and DCIA; BMPFast spreads the Treatment Volume over all the area draining to the BMP, with area-weighted CN and DCIA, and reads the tables there.
Worked example
Catchment 2 (99 ac, no treatment) routed to catchment 1 (1 ac) with a retention basin of 4.167 ac-ft, in Florida Zone 2 with Non-DCIA CN 70 and DCIA 24.33 % in both. The catchments produce 100.01 kg/yr of nitrogen.
Treatment Depth = 12 × 4.167 / 100 = 0.500 in
Capture = retention curves at 0.50 in = 75.31 %
N at the outlet = 100.01 × (1 − 75.31 / 100) = 24.70 kg/yr
Over its own acre the same basin would hold 50 in, far more than that acre’s runoff; over the 100 acres that drain to it, 0.5 in.
Other methods
A. The BMP’s own Treatment Depth, applied to all the load
The Treatment Depth over the BMP’s own catchment, applied to all the load reaching it. This is also what the Retention in Series rule (Treatment Depths added) gives here, because the untreated catchments add no depth.
Treatment Depth (in) = 12 × Treatment Volume / own catchment's area (the curves are read at 4 in at most)
Applicant’s Handbook reference
Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: the printed tables run from 0.25 to 4.00 inches of retention for each zone; BMPFast reads the curves at 4 in for any larger depth.
B. The upstream runoff bypasses the BMP
The BMP treats only its own catchment, and the upstream runoff goes on untreated. This is what BMPFast does when the catchment is set to bypass upstream runoff on the Routing screen (always for Rainwater Harvesting and Greenroof): then the strand is not calculated as one system.
The differences
| Method | Treatment Depth (in) | N removal of the strand (%) | N at the outlet (kg/yr) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Used: Treatment Volume over all the area draining to it | 0.50 | 75.3 | 24.70 |
| A. Own Treatment Depth, on all the load | 50 (read at 4) | 99.0 | 1.00 |
| B. Upstream runoff bypasses the BMP | 50 (own load only) | 1.0 | 99.02 |
Method A treats the runoff of 100 acres as if the basin held 50 inches of it, which it cannot. Method B treats only the basin’s own acre. Spreading the volume over all the area that drains to the basin is the only method in which the basin holds the water that actually reaches it. (For phosphorus the removals are the same: N removal = P removal = capture.)
The methods over a range of basin sizes
Here the basin’s Treatment Volume goes from 0.42 to 16.7 ac-ft, that is 0.05 to 2 in over the 100 acres draining to it. The method used, B (bypass) and node by node (ComplexRouting.Calculate) were calculated by the program; node by node gives the same numbers as the method used. A is put together from the program’s retention curve for catchment 1 at the basin’s own Treatment Depth.
| Treatment Volume (ac-ft) | Depth over 100 ac / over its own 1 ac (in) | BMPFast (%) | A. Own depth (%) | B. Bypass (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.42 | 0.05 / 5 | 11.4 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 0.83 | 0.1 / 10 | 22.9 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 2.08 | 0.25 / 25 | 57.2 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 4.17 | 0.5 / 50 | 75.3 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 6.25 | 0.75 / 75 | 83.2 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 8.33 | 1 / 100 | 88.0 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 10.42 | 1.25 / 125 | 91.0 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 12.50 | 1.5 / 150 | 93.1 | 99.0 | 1.0 |
| 16.67 | 2 / 200 | 95.7 | 99.0 | 1.0 |

What the comparison shows
- Method A credits 99 % from the smallest basin here, because 0.42 ac-ft is 5 in over one acre and the curves are read at 4 in at most. It ignores that 100 acres drain to the basin.
- The method used rises with the volume as the retention curves do, from 11 % at 0.05 in to 96 % at 2 in.
- Bypass (B) treats only the basin’s own acre, so the strand’s removal stays near 1 %.
Source reference
BMPFast’s method: spreading the Treatment Volume over all the area draining to the BMP, with area-weighted CN and DCIA, is BMPFast’s reading of the handbook’s “inches over the catchment area”, the same as for a retention BMP at a junction (plan 6.84).
Sample problems
Worked problems solved in BMPFast, each with every input, the steps with screen captures, the program’s results, a hand check and the project file to download. Captures are for demonstration only. All of them: BMPFast sample problems.
- Routing: untreated catchment into a retention basin
- Routing: wet ponds in series (2020 manual)
- Routing: two subdivisions joining at a wet pond
Related pages
- Routing: how runoff moves between catchments, and what a strand is.
- Wet Detention Methodology: residence time and the pond equations.
- Retention Methodology and Retention BMPs: the retention curves and each BMP’s Treatment Depth.
- BMPs in Series: several BMPs in one catchment (Multiple BMP).
- Discovery Plots Methodology: plots that repeat the whole routing.
- Comparison of Methods for Calculating Retention BMPs in Series.