Comparison of Methods for Calculating the Littoral Zone Credit

The Applicant’s Handbook gives a wet pond with a littoral zone a “maximum 10% removal” more. It does not say whether the pond equations describe a pond with a littoral zone or one without, so the credit can be read two ways. This page shows both on one pond (Wet Detention) and over the range of residence times.

BMPFast 2 adds the credit (Ron, October 20, 2026: “This will be a 10% credit for having a littoral zone, it is no longer a penalty”): a pond with a littoral zone adds the credit the designer enters, up to 10 percentage points. BMPFast (version 1) reduces: a pond without a littoral zone gets 90 % of the equations’ removal. BMPFast 2 keeps v1’s reduction as a choice on the pond’s Entry tab, “How the littoral zone counts”.

The equations’ values and version 1’s figures were calculated by BMPFast version 1 (the Release build of October 16, 2026). The credit’s figures are the equations’ values plus 10, which is what BMPFast 2 gives with the full credit.

The problem

Example Problem 5’s wet pond: a permanent pool of 3.809 ac-ft receiving 13.90 ac-ft/yr of runoff, no MAPs credit.

Residence time = 3.809 / 13.90 x 365 = 100.0 days
N removal (equation) = 43.75 x 100.0 / (4.38 + 100.0) = 41.91 %
P removal (equation) = 40.13 + 6.372 ln(100.0) + 0.213 [ln(100.0)]^2 = 73.99 %

The method BMPFast 2 uses: a credit for a littoral zone

The equations are taken as a pond without a littoral zone. A pond without one gets the equations’ removal; a pond with one gets the credit the designer enters added to it, from 0 to 10 percentage points (10 unless a smaller littoral zone calls for less), to both nitrogen and phosphorus, and never above 100 %. The credit is added before the MAPs credit.

With a littoral zone:    removal = equation + credit   (credit 0 to 10 percentage points)
Without a littoral zone: removal = equation
Example, credit 10, with: N 51.91 %, P 83.99 %; without: N 41.91 %, P 73.99 %

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Table 1 (BMP Efficiencies), Littoral Zone: gives “Maximum 10% removal with a minimum littoral zone area as described in AH Volume II”; it does not say which pond the equations describe.

Appendix O, Wet Detention: gives the TN and TP percent removal equations against the residence time.

Source reference

BMPFast 2’s reading (Ron, October 20, 2026): the equations, from Harper, H.H. and Baker, D.M. (2007), Evaluation of Current Stormwater Design Criteria within the State of Florida, final report, FDEP Contract S0108, Environmental Research & Design, are taken as a pond without a littoral zone, and a pond with one adds a credit of up to 10 percentage points, entered by the designer. The credit is taken only once in ponds in series (Ron, October 16, 2026).

BMPFast (version 1)’s method: a reduction without a littoral zone

The equations are taken as a pond with a littoral zone. A pond with one gets the equations’ removal, and a pond without one gets 90 % of it (Ron, October 5, 2026; before then it was / 1.10, which is 0.909, almost the same). BMPFast version 1 calculates this way; in BMPFast 2 it is the choice “Reduce without a littoral zone (v1)”. A v1 project opened in BMPFast 2 uses the credit, and BMPFast 2 says so when it opens it.

With a littoral zone:    removal = equation
Without a littoral zone: removal = equation x 0.90
Example, with: N 41.91 %, P 73.99 %; without: N 37.72 %, P 66.59 %

The two methods compared

PondBMPFast 2 (credit 10 with a littoral zone): N / P (%)BMPFast v1 (x 0.90 without a littoral zone): N / P (%)BMPFast 2 minus v1: N / P (points)
With a littoral zone51.9 / 84.041.9 / 74.010.0 / 10.0
Without a littoral zone41.9 / 74.037.7 / 66.64.2 / 7.4
Residence time (days)Equations, N / P (%) (BMPFast 2 without a littoral zone = v1 with one)BMPFast 2 with a littoral zone, equations + 10: N / P (%)BMPFast v1 without a littoral zone, equations x 0.90: N / P (%)
18.1 / 40.118.1 / 50.17.3 / 36.1
213.7 / 44.623.7 / 54.612.3 / 40.2
523.3 / 50.933.3 / 60.921.0 / 45.8
1030.4 / 55.940.4 / 65.927.4 / 50.3
1433.3 / 58.443.3 / 68.430.0 / 52.6
2035.9 / 61.145.9 / 71.132.3 / 55.0
3038.2 / 64.348.2 / 74.334.4 / 57.8
5040.2 / 68.350.2 / 78.336.2 / 61.5
7541.3 / 71.651.3 / 81.637.2 / 64.5
10041.9 / 74.051.9 / 84.037.7 / 66.6
15042.5 / 77.452.5 / 87.438.3 / 69.7
20042.8 / 79.952.8 / 89.938.5 / 71.9

The plots below were drawn before BMPFast 2 took the credit, so their legend names the lines the old way:

  • “BMPFast, pond with a littoral zone (the equations)”: version 1 with a littoral zone, and also BMPFast 2 without one.
  • “BMPFast, pond without a littoral zone (x 0.90)”: version 1 without a littoral zone.
  • “Other reading, pond with a littoral zone (equations + 10 points)”: BMPFast 2 with a littoral zone and the full credit.
The littoral zone credit: nitrogen removal by each method against the residence time
The littoral zone credit: nitrogen removal by each method against the residence time
The littoral zone credit: phosphorus removal by each method against the residence time
The littoral zone credit: phosphorus removal by each method against the residence time

What the comparison shows

  • BMPFast 2’s credit gives every pond more removal than v1’s reduction: 10 points more with a littoral zone (at the full credit), and the equations’ value instead of 90 % of it without one (4.2 points of N and 7.4 of P on the worked example).
  • With the credit a littoral zone is always worth the points entered, 10 at most. In v1’s reduction it is worth 10 % of the pond’s removal, so from under 1 point of nitrogen at 1 day to 8 points of phosphorus at 200 days.
  • A pond without a littoral zone is no longer penalised: it gets the handbook’s equations, which at the 200-day limit give 42.8 % N and 79.9 % P. With the full credit the same pond reaches 52.8 % N and 89.9 % P.

Which method each version uses, and why. BMPFast 2 uses the credit (Ron, October 20, 2026): the handbook names the littoral zone as removal it adds, “Maximum 10% removal”, so the designer enters up to 10 points and gives the basis to the permit reviewer. BMPFast version 1 uses the reduction (Ron, October 5, 2026), and BMPFast 2 keeps it as a choice so a v1 result can be repeated.