Retention Efficiency Lookup Tables

The Retention Efficiency calculator looks up the mean annual mass removal efficiency of a retention system — the share of the annual runoff (and so of the pollutant load) that a given treatment depth captures — from the Florida retention efficiency tables that BMPFast uses for every retention-type BMP. It also works backwards: given an efficiency, it finds the curve number or the DCIA percent that produces it. Open it from Tools (Calculators) with the Retention Efficiency Lookup Tables button. Nothing entered here is saved or changes the project.

Inputs

InputUnitsWhat it means / how it is used
Rainfall Zone—Florida Zone 1 to Florida Zone 5. Each zone has its own tables. Opens on the project’s rainfall zone; after a Find it keeps the zone you picked, the one the answer is for.
Treatment Depth (0-4 in)in over the watershedThe treatment (retention) depth. The tables are for 0.25 to 4.00 in, every 0.25 in; between two tables BMPFast interpolates. Below 0.25 in the efficiency is interpolated from 0% at 0 in to the 0.25 in value. Depths above 4.00 in use the 4.00 in table, and Find beside Efficiency changes such a depth to 4.00 in its box. A depth of 0 gives 0% efficiency.
NDCIA CN—Curve number of the non-directly-connected impervious area (the pervious part of the watershed). The tables run from 30 to 98.
DCIA %%Directly connected impervious area as a percent of the watershed. The tables run from 5 to 100; a value below 5 is looked up at 5, and Find beside Efficiency raises the box to 5 so it shows the value used.
Efficiency%Mean annual mass removal efficiency. An answer when you click Find beside it; an input when you use the Find beside NDCIA CN or DCIA %.

Buttons

ButtonWhat it does
Find (beside Efficiency)Calculates the efficiency for the Rainfall Zone, Treatment Depth, NDCIA CN and DCIA %, and shows the table for that depth. A DCIA % below 5 is changed to 5, and a Treatment Depth above 4 to 4, in their boxes first.
Find (beside NDCIA CN)Finds the NDCIA curve number that gives the entered Efficiency at the entered DCIA % and depth. The answer is held between 30 and 98.
Find (beside DCIA %)Finds the DCIA percent that gives the entered Efficiency at the entered NDCIA CN and depth. The answer is held between 5 and 100, the range of the tables.
CopyCopies the table shown to the clipboard.
HelpOpens this page.
BackCloses the calculator. Nothing is saved; copy the table first if you want to keep it.

Results

The answer appears in its box. Below, the table for the depth entered is shown: rows are NDCIA CN (30 to 98), columns are Percent DCIA (5 to 100), and each cell is the mean annual mass removal efficiency (%). For a depth between two tabulated depths, the table is interpolated cell by cell and titled “Efficiency at Retention Depth: {depth} (in) for Rainfall {zone}”.

Method

Tabulated depths: 0.00, 0.25, 0.50, ... 4.00 in
D1 = tabulated depth at or below the Treatment Depth D, D2 = the next tabulated depth
E1 = table(D1, zone) at (NDCIA CN, DCIA %), E2 = table(D2, zone) at (NDCIA CN, DCIA %)
(bilinear interpolation within each table; DCIA % below 5 uses 5)
Efficiency = E1 + (D - D1) / (D2 - D1) x (E2 - E1)
(if E1 is greater than E2, Efficiency = E2)

This is the same lookup BMPFast uses to find the Hydraulic Capture Efficiency of retention BMPs and of the Surface Discharge Filter from their treatment depth. The reverse finds interpolate within the table for the entered depth; where the table’s values do not change steadily with the curve number, the curve-number answer stops at the last value that does.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: the tables “Mean Annual Mass Removal Efficiencies for … of Retention for Zone … by Percent DCIA” cover 0.25 to 4.00 in of retention in Zones 1 to 5, non-DCIA CN 30 to 98 and DCIA 5 to 100 %, and “For DCIA and CN other than increments of 5, linear interpolation between the values is performed”; this calculator shows those tables and interpolates the same way. Interpolating between depths, and from 0 below 0.25 in, is BMPFast’s own; the handbook does not describe it.

Appendix O, Table 1 (BMP Efficiencies), Retention Pond and Retention Systems: removal is based on the project’s DCIA, non-DCIA curve number and rainfall zone, the inputs of this calculator.

Source reference

Harper, H.H. and Baker, D.M. (2007). Evaluation of Current Stormwater Design Criteria within the State of Florida. Final report, FDEP Contract S0108, Appendix D (Calculated Performance Efficiency of Dry Retention as a Function of DCIA and Non-DCIA Curve Number) and Section 5.2.1.1 (Evaluation Methodology) (link): the retention tables come from a continuous simulation of each zone’s rainfall record, with a dry pond that recovers 50 % of its volume in 24 hours and all of it in 72 hours; BMPFast’s tables, 0.25 to 4.00 in for Zones 1 to 5, match the report value for value.

BMPFast method (RetentionEfficiencyLookupTables.CalculateEfficiency): interpolation between depth tables, the 0 in table and the edge rules are BMPFast’s.

Sample problems

Worked problems solved in BMPFast, each with every input, the steps with screen captures, the program’s results, a hand check and the project file to download. Captures are for demonstration only. All of them: BMPFast sample problems.