Comparison of Methods for Calculating Retention BMPs in Series

Two or more retention BMPs one after the other in a catchment (BMPs in Series) can be calculated two ways, and they give different results. BMPFast treats them as one storage and adds their Treatment Depths. The other way, Equation 9-5 of the Applicant’s Handbook, treats each BMP as independent and chains their removals. This page solves one problem both ways and compares them over a range of sizes.

Every number on this page was calculated by the BMPFast program (the Release build of October 16, 2026). A method that BMPFast does not run is put together from the program’s own results, as each section says.

The problem

Example Problem 5 (a BMPFast test project): a 6 ac highway catchment in Florida Zone 5, Non-DCIA Curve Number 80, DCIA 60 %, 61 in of rain a year. The BMPs sit on 1 ac of it, so the Treatment Depths are over the other 5 ac. Annual runoff is 13.90 ac-ft, carrying 21.43 kg/yr of nitrogen and 2.966 kg/yr of phosphorus.

BMPTypeTreatment Volume (ac-ft)Treatment Depth (in)Removal on its own (%)
1Permeable Pavement0.2750.6657.9
2Retention0.3130.751262.1

Each BMP’s own removal is its capture from the retention curves at its own Treatment Depth (Retention Methodology, Retention BMPs).

The method BMPFast uses: Treatment Depths added

The retention BMPs in a row are one system. Their Treatment Depths are added; the sum, the Equivalent Treatment Depth, is read once on the retention curves; that capture is the removal of nitrogen and of phosphorus for the whole series.

Equivalent Treatment Depth (in) = Treatment Depth 1 + Treatment Depth 2 (+ 3 + 4)
Removal (%) = capture from the retention curves at the Equivalent Treatment Depth (catchment CN, DCIA, zone)
Example: 0.66 + 0.7512 = 1.4112 in -> 78.91 %

The series lets through 4.52 kg/yr of nitrogen and 0.626 kg/yr of phosphorus.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: removal is read from the mean annual mass removal tables at the retention depth in inches over the catchment area; the handbook does not describe retention BMPs in series.

Section 9.5.1 Treatment Train Nutrient Reduction: Equation 9-5, 1 − [(1 − Eff1) × (1 − Eff2)], combines BMPs that act independently; where a BMP acts in combination with the one upstream, “the designer should consider the use of another methodology”.

Source reference

BMPFast’s method, from the BMPTrains model: adding the Treatment Depths of retention BMPs in series is the BMPTrains model’s rule (BMP Trains 2020 User Manual, Stormwater Management Academy, University of Central Florida, December 2021 (stars.library.ucf.edu/bmptrains/25)), kept in BMPFast (MultipleBMP.CalculateEquivalentRetentionDepth); since October 1, 2026 it also applies when retention BMPs lead a mixed series, and since October 15, 2026 to retention BMPs in series between catchments (Ron).

The other method: Equation 9-5

Each BMP keeps its own removal, and the second removes its share of what the first lets through. BMPFast does not calculate retention BMPs in series this way; the figures below are the program’s two stand-alone removals, combined by Equation 9-5.

Removal (%) = 100 x [1 - (1 - removal 1 / 100) x (1 - removal 2 / 100)]
Example: 100 x [1 - (1 - 0.5785) x (1 - 0.6214)] = 84.04 %

The series would let through 3.42 kg/yr of nitrogen and 0.473 kg/yr of phosphorus.

The two methods compared

MethodDepths used (in)N and P removal (%)N out (kg/yr)P out (kg/yr)
BMPFast: Treatment Depths added0.66 + 0.7512 = 1.411278.94.520.626
Equation 9-5, each BMP on its own0.66, then 0.751284.03.420.473

Over a range: the permeable pavement stays at 0.66 in and the retention basin goes from 0.1 to 3 in.

Basin Treatment Depth (in)Basin alone (%)Equivalent Treatment Depth (in)BMPFast (%)Equation 9-5 (%)Difference (points)
0.112.70.7662.463.20.8
0.2531.70.9167.371.23.9
0.550.31.1674.179.15.0
0.7562.11.4178.984.05.1
170.31.6682.587.55.0
1.2576.21.9185.490.04.6
1.580.42.1687.691.74.2
286.32.6690.994.23.3
2.590.03.1693.195.82.7
392.53.6694.796.82.1
Two retention BMPs in series: removal by each method against the Treatment Depth of the second
Two retention BMPs in series: removal by each method against the Treatment Depth of the second

What the comparison shows

  • Equation 9-5 always gives more removal, here 0.8 to 5.1 percentage points more (5.1 on the worked example).
  • The reason is the storms. Each retention BMP holds the first part of every storm. Once the first is full, the water that reaches the second comes from the larger storms, and the second fills quickly too. Equation 9-5 credits the second BMP with its full removal on that water, as if it saw the same mix of storms as the first. Adding the depths treats the two as one storage that holds the first (depth 1 + depth 2) inches of each storm.
  • The gap is widest when the two BMPs are about the same size, and closes as either one becomes large (both methods then approach 100 %).
  • In one catchment both depths are over the same area, so adding the depths is the same as putting all the volume over that area. Between catchments the two are not the same: see Strand Based Routing for Retention in Series.

Which BMPFast uses, and why. Adding the depths: the BMPs hold water from the same storms, so they are not independent, which is the case section 9.5.1 sets aside for “another methodology”. The same rule is used for retention BMPs in series between catchments (Ron, October 15, 2026).