Greenroof

The Greenroof worksheet calculates the average annual nitrogen (TN) and phosphorus (TP) removal of a greenroof, with or without a cistern that stores the filtrate for irrigation. You open it from the catchment’s treatment choices. The catchment must be the roof itself: its area is the greenroof area. You choose the nearest rainfall station and enter the cistern storage; BMPFast returns the fraction of the annual roof runoff that is retained and used on site.

Description

A Greenroof is a vegetated cover on a roof membrane. It is usually followed by storage in a cistern (or other similar device) for the filtrate that is harvested for irrigation of the plants on the roof or for other beneficial purposes. A greenroof and cistern system is classified as a retention and harvesting BMP. Effectiveness is the annual volume of roof runoff that is captured, retained, and used on site. The term harvesting is preferred to avoid confusion with wastewater reuse.

A cistern is sized for a specific amount of filtrate and receives no other stormwater. The retained water is used to irrigate the roof since experience in Florida has shown that irrigation must be provided to maintain the plants. A backup source of water for irrigation is necessary during the dry season. Excess filtrate and excess runoff can be discharged to other stormwater treatment systems, infiltrated into the ground, or used for irrigation or other non-potable purposes.

The greenroof and cistern system functions to attenuate, evaporate, and thus lower the volume of discharge and pollutant load coming from the roof surface. Greenroof systems have been shown to assist in stormwater management by:

  • Attenuating hydrographs
  • Neutralizing acid rain
  • Reducing the volume of discharge
  • Reducing the annual mass of pollutants discharged

They are frequently used on commercial or public buildings, but have also been successfully used on residences.

If no cistern is used, the greenroof will provide some storage and eventual evapotranspiration. The BMPFast software also provides estimates of annual removal effectiveness when no cistern is used.

Greenroof Classifications

Green roofs are classified in two ways:

  1. By Access to the Finished Roof
    • Passive – access limited to maintenance personnel
    • Active – accessible to the public or building occupants
  2. By Root Zone Depth
    • Extensive – root zone less than 6 inches deep
    • Intensive – root zone equal to or greater than 6 inches deep

Extensive green roofs typically have passive use.

Intensive green roofs support larger plants and are typically active designs.

Extensive Green Roof Section

Figure 12.1a – Typical cross section of an Extensive Greenroof used for passive designs.

Intensive Green Roof Section

Figure 12.1b – Typical cross section of an Intensive Greenroof used for active designs.

Wind Mitigation

As an option to the use of wind netting, a parapet usually 30 inches or more in height is used to minimize wind damage during high wind conditions. The use of wind mitigation procedures does not affect the annual removal effectiveness of a green roof.

How to use this worksheet

  1. Set up the catchment so that its area is the greenroof area. The Greenroof Area (Square Feet) box is filled from the catchment’s post-development area and cannot be edited here.
  2. Choose the rainfall station nearest the project in Select Rainfall Station.
  3. Enter the Cistern Storage provided over Greenroof Area (0.00-5.0 in), or 0 if there is no cistern (any other value must be from 0.01 to 5 in).
  4. Optional: for a water budget of the cistern, enter Irrigation Demand (in/year) and Rainfall Excess (filtrate underdrain flow, in/year). Leave them at 0 if you do not need one; they do not change the removal.
  5. Click Calculate. The report appears in the lower pane. Click the same button (now Equations) to see the equations and values used; click again (Report) to return to the report.
  6. Click Back to keep the values and return to the catchment.

Inputs

Input (as on screen)UnitsWhat it means / how it is used
Select Rainfall StationchoiceOne of 18 Florida stations: Belle Glade #616, Boca Raton #845, Brooksville #1048, Daytona #2158, Fort Meyers #3186, Gainesville #3321, Homestead #4091, Jacksonville #4358, Key West #4570, Lakeland #4797, Miami #5663, Niceville #6240, Orlando #6628, Panama City #6842, Tallahassee #8758, Tampa #8788, Venice #9176, West Palm Beach #9525. Each station supplies the coefficients of its removal curve (a, b) and its no-cistern removal (c). No calculation is done until a station is selected, and Sizing asks you to select one first.
Greenroof Area (Square Feet):sfRead-only. Set to the catchment’s post-development area × 43,560 each time the worksheet opens. It is listed in the report; the removal does not depend on it.
Cistern Storage provided over Greenroof Area (0.00-5.0 in):in over the greenroof areaVolume of the cistern expressed as a depth over the greenroof area (1.604 inches over one square foot = 1 gallon, so inches = gallons × 1.604 / greenroof area in sf). 0 = no cistern. Shown in the report as Treatment Depth (in). Enter 0 (no cistern) or a value from 0.01 to 5 in: the worksheet refuses anything else when you Calculate, size or go Back (below 0.01 in the curve gives a removal below zero for some stations). Sizing steps it by 0.25 in between 0 and 5 in.
Irrigation Demand (in/year):in/yr over the greenroof areaOptional. The water the roof plants need in a year. Used only for the Water Budget (Irrigation Water Use); it does not change the removal.
Rainfall Excess (filtrate underdrain flow, in/year):in/yr over the greenroof areaOptional. The filtrate that drains from the roof media to the cistern in a year. Used only for the Water Budget (Harvested Water Supply).

Input Data

There are two (2) required input parameters (the water-budget inputs are optional):

  1. Rainfall Station
  2. Cistern Storage (inches over the greenroof area)

The rainfall station selected must reflect the geographic area of the project or the closest available location. There is a drop-down menu containing 18 locations. Each location supplies rainfall data used for simulation over at least 25 years.

The greenroof area must be the same as the catchment area.  In this case it was one acre or 43,560 SF.  The cistern size is 25,000 gallons or 0.9206 inches over 43,560 SF. The project is located in the Jacksonville area. The annual retention is 63%. 

 There is an option to use no cistern by entering zero as the cistern storage.  For this example, the capture is 40% as shown in the software screen capture below.

Method and equations

Methodology. Harvesting and Greenroof Methodology compares the greenroof curves with the harvesting method, with a plot for three stations.

The greenroof removal is a curve fitted for each rainfall station. These equations are shown on the worksheet’s Equations page:

Treatment Depth (in) = Cistern Storage (in over Greenroof Area)
Removal Efficiency (%) = c (Cistern Storage = 0, no cistern)
Removal Efficiency (%) = max(c, a x ln(Cistern Storage) + b) (Cistern Storage > 0)
N removal (%) = P removal (%) = Removal Efficiency (%)
N load out (kg/yr) = N load in x (100 - N removal) / 100 (likewise for P)

Water Budget (only when Irrigation Demand or Rainfall Excess is entered; gallons per year):

Irrigation Water Use (gal/yr) = Irrigation Demand (in/yr) / 12 x Greenroof Area (sf) x 7.48052 gal/cf
Harvested Water Supply (gal/yr) = Removal Efficiency / 100 x Rainfall Excess (in/yr) / 12 x Greenroof Area (sf) x 7.48052 gal/cf (0 with no cistern)
Supplemental Water Needed (gal/yr) = Irrigation Water Use - Harvested Water Supply (never below 0)

a, b and c are the coefficients of the selected rainfall station. For example, Jacksonville #4358 has a = 11.49, b = 64.23 and c = 40: with 0.9206 in of cistern storage the removal is 11.49 × ln(0.9206) + 64.23 = 63%; with no cistern it is 40%. A cistern never gives less removal than no cistern: below about 0.11 to 0.16 in of storage the curve a × ln(storage) + b falls under c (Jacksonville at 0.1 in: 37.8%), so the program uses c (40%) there. The removal is a retention credit: the retained water is used on site, so the same fraction of the runoff volume is removed.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Green Roof: says the nutrient reduction “can be calculated in the same way as Dry Retention System”; BMPFast differs: it uses a removal curve fitted for each of 18 rainfall stations from the cistern storage, not the dry retention tables. BMPFast 2 lets you choose either: the station curves, or the dry retention tables with the roof’s storage as the retention depth. The AH Vol. I compliance report says which is used.

Appendix O, Table 1 (BMP Efficiencies), Green Stormwater Infrastructure Efforts: Green Roofs are listed with “Use appropriate retention or detention calculation for volume captured then add an additional removal based on plant, soil and media selections”; BMPFast credits only the volume retained and used on site, with no added plant or media removal.

Source reference

Hardin, M. (2006). The Effectiveness of a Specifically Designed Green Roof Stormwater Treatment System Irrigated with Recycled Stormwater Runoff to Achieve Pollutant Removal and Stormwater Volume Reduction. M.S. thesis, University of Central Florida (link): long-term simulations of a green roof with a cistern at 18 Florida rainfall stations give, for each station, the yearly retention against the cistern storage in inches over the roof; BMPFast’s coefficients a, b and c for each station come from these curves.

FDEP and the water management districts (2010). Stormwater Quality Applicant’s Handbook: Design Requirements for Stormwater Treatment Systems in Florida, March 2010 draft (not adopted), Section 12.8 Greenroof Cistern/Harvesting Design Curves and Equations (the draft, not adopted: PDF, 16 MB): gives a curve % retention = a Ln(S) + b for each of the same 18 stations (Belle Glade: 10.70 Ln(S) + 72.36, about 50 % with no cistern), for cistern storage S from 0.5 to 5.0 in; BMPFast uses the same coefficients and accepts 0.01 to 5 in, using the no-cistern value below about 0.11 to 0.16 in.

BMPFast method (Reuse.cs and Greenroof.cs; Ron, 2026-10-12): using the larger of c and a × ln(storage) + b, so a small cistern never scores below none, is BMPFast’s rule.

The Equations page

Once the report is current, the Calculate button reads Equations. Clicking it shows the equations above, the notes (Cistern Storage is entered directly; a and b are the coefficients of the selected Rainfall Station; c is the station’s removal with no cistern, and a cistern never gives less than c; N and P removal are equal; the water budget is calculated only when its inputs are entered and does not change the removal), the Water Budget equations, and a Values table: Greenroof Storage, Contributing Area, Watershed Area, Non-DCIA Curve Number, DCIA Percent, Rainfall Zone, Treatment Depth, Hydraulic Capture, Treatment Rate (“no media mix”), N removal and P removal. Click again (Report) to return to the report.

Results (the report)

  • Greenroof Input Variables: Selected Rainfall Station, Greenroof Area (sf), Treatment Depth (in) = the cistern storage; and Irrigation Demand and Rainfall Excess (in/yr) when entered.
  • Water Budget (when Irrigation Demand or Rainfall Excess is entered): Irrigation Water Use, Harvested Water Supply and Supplemental Water Needed, in gal/yr. Supplemental Water Needed is the irrigation water that must come from another source, such as the backup supply for the dry season.
  • Watershed Characteristics: Watershed Area (acres), Contributing Area to BMP (ac), Watershed Non-DCIA Curve Number, Watershed DCIA Percent, Rainfall Zone, Rainfall (in).
  • Surface Water Discharge: Provided Nitrogen and Phosphorus Treatment Efficiency (%). A value of 100% or more is shown as 99%.
  • Groundwater Discharge (Stand-Alone): Average Annual Recharge (MG/yr) and the TN and TP mass load (kg/yr) and concentration (mg/L) of the groundwater discharge.
  • Surface Discharge Load Diagram: N and P loads and runoff volume into the greenroof, the removal, the loads and volume discharged, and the mass removed, for this catchment alone.

Buttons and features

ButtonWhat it does
Calculate / Equations / ReportCalculate appears whenever the inputs differ from those the report was calculated with; it reads the inputs, calculates and shows the report. When the report is current the button toggles between the Equations page and the Report.
SizingOpens the Sizing window with one variable, Greenroof Storage (in over the greenroof area, 0–5 in in steps of 0.25). It plots N and P removal against the storage with the removal targets (defaulting to the project’s Maximum % Removal). Apply keeps the new storage on the worksheet; Cancel restores the original. If no rainfall station is selected it says “Select a Rainfall Station before sizing a Greenroof.” See Sizing.
CostOpens the Life-Cycle Cost Analysis for this greenroof.
PrintOpens what is shown in the lower pane in the Report Viewer, where it can be printed or copied.
HelpOpens this page.
BackSaves the values entered, recalculates and closes the worksheet.

The status bar at the bottom of the window shows the project’s Maximum % Removal for TN and TP.

Notes and limits

  • The catchment area must equal the greenroof area (the note on the worksheet). Put other areas of the site in their own catchments.
  • A greenroof treats only the rain that falls on its own roof; flows routed from upstream catchments bypass it.
  • Without a rainfall station no removal is calculated.
  • Wind mitigation (netting or a parapet) does not change the annual removal.

Sample problems

Worked problems solved in BMPFast, each with every input, the steps with screen captures, the program’s results, a hand check and the project file to download. Captures are for demonstration only. All of them: BMPFast sample problems.